Torn Between My Stepbrothers
71 Episodes
Hailey has been crushing on Derek for years, only to discover on the day she plans to confess that he is now with her best friend. Heartbroken, she drinks alone and is harassed, but is rescued by Tyler. Mistaking him for Derek, Hailey believes they share a one-night stand—only to wake and realize he is her stepbrother and Derek's older brother.